Supplement II: Was there a lost Underwater adventure?

[Havard]

That'd be nice, but I've never seen anything that would even hint at such a thing. Plus the TOtF itself is a pretty big work. Not sure Dave would have had time to write another scenario unless it was a fairly short kinda thing.

Fair points.

The thing that got me thinking about it were the details on the underwater mages. It seems like a reference taken from something else and brought in with some context missing. Of course another possibility is that it was taken from something written by Steven Marsh or Tim Kask, but still edited in a way where something was cut...

I'm also not convinced there is a whole lot of "lost" material from supplement II. Dave tended to recycle, and it seems likely to me that some of that stuff showed up later. Especially, I'd bet dollars to donunts that the "Special Interests" section of the FFC was part of the material Dave submitted for Supp II that got cut.

Interesting theory! I think the Special Interest section could have worked very well with OD&D, especially with some modifications. Any particular reason why you think this particular section is what was discarded? I agree that the things being cut likely appeared in the FFC, but never gave any thought to what specific sections might have been submitted.


-Havard