+- The Comeback Inn (https://blackmoor.mystara.us/forums)
+-- Forum: The Garnet Room - Blackmoor General Forum (https://blackmoor.mystara.us/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=34)
+--- Forum: Blackmoor Rules Discussion (https://blackmoor.mystara.us/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=26)
+---- Forum: D&D 5E Blackmoor (https://blackmoor.mystara.us/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=64)
+---- Thread: [5E] Classes for Blackmoor? (/showthread.php?tid=1956)
Pages:
1
2
[5E] Classes for Blackmoor? - Havard - 02-05-2015
Anyone here thinking of running a D&D 5th Edition Campaign in Blackmoor? If so, how do you see the various classes and class paths fitting into this setting?
-Havard
Re: [5E] Classes for Blackmoor? - RobJN - 02-05-2015
I would run it in a heartbeat. The flavor of much of the 5th Edition lines up very well with the Thorn's World That Was mythology.
Magic being wild and abundant, even the lowliest of fighters and thieves are able to work a touch or two of magic.
Warlocks with the alien-being pact are just screaming to be used as servants of the Egg or the entity of Id.
And the new Unearthed Arcana article series gives us artificers to play with, as well... :?:
Re: [5E] Classes for Blackmoor? - Vile - 02-07-2015
Just sticking with the free Basic PDF could work, but I also like the standard classes in the PHB. I tend to see Blackmoor as the gonzo of the already gonzo OD&D, so no holds barred.
Re: [5E] Classes for Blackmoor? - finarvyn - 02-08-2015
I'd love to see 5E Blackmoor "done right." I probably wouldn't be able to do much with it right away since I'm running the DRAGON HOARD mega-adventure at the local game store, but I'd be interested in reading a 5E Blackmoor doc if someone threw it together.
In many ways I prefer starting with the "core four" from the basic PDF, mostly because I think some of the other classes are sort of broken in places, but I also agree that Blackmoor can certainly handle pretty much any of the classes in the 5E Player's Handbook.
As we've discussed elsewhere, Blackmoor is an attitude more than a specific rules set. 8)
Re: [5E] Classes for Blackmoor? - Havard - 02-09-2015
RobJN Wrote:Warlocks with the alien-being pact are just screaming to be used as servants of the Egg or the entity of Id.
Sounds perfect 8)
I wonder if you could also have Elemental Pact Warlocks to simulate Elven Elementalists from 3E?
Quote:And the new Unearthed Arcana article series gives us artificers to play with, as well... :?:
Link for this?
-Havard
Re: [5E] Classes for Blackmoor? - RobJN - 02-09-2015
Havard Wrote:RobJN Wrote:Warlocks with the alien-being pact are just screaming to be used as servants of the Egg or the entity of Id.
Sounds perfect 8)
I wonder if you could also have Elemental Pact Warlocks to simulate Elven Elementalists from 3E?
Or reskin in the Draconic bloodlines for sorcerers into their elemental niche...
Quote:http://dnd.wizards.com/articles/feature ... na-eberronQuote:And the new Unearthed Arcana article series gives us artificers to play with, as well... :?:
Link for this?
-Havard
Re: [5E] Classes for Blackmoor? - Havard - 02-09-2015
finarvyn Wrote:I'd love to see 5E Blackmoor "done right."
I am curious about this statement. Would that mean ignoring much of the 3E ZGG Blackmoor line? How about the DA modules?
Obviously rules and setting are to some degree separate, but the treatment of mages and the Wizards Cabal/Sorcerers could affect class options for instance
-Havard
Re: [5E] Classes for Blackmoor? - finarvyn - 02-15-2015
Havard Wrote:I don't have a specific era in mind, if that's your question. :lol:finarvyn Wrote:I'd love to see 5E Blackmoor "done right."I am curious about this statement. Would that mean ignoring much of the 3E ZGG Blackmoor line? How about the DA modules?
I guess I'm thinking that a 5E Blackmoor book actually designed to capture Blackmoor is what I have in mind, as opposed to taking Forgotten Realms material and having to fit a "square peg in a round hole", as they say. I'd like to be able to hold up a book (and/or DM screen, or whatever) and say "here is the Blackmoor campaign in 5E" or something like that.
If this means taking the ZGG Blackmoor line and getting it redone, that's fine. If it means going back to the DA modules and getting it redone, that's fine. I know that I can "wing it" with 5E rules, but it would be nice to see an "official" setting on the market again.
Re: [5E] Classes for Blackmoor? - Havard - 02-16-2015
Okay, I guess I was reading too much into your statement
I totally agree with you when it comes to avoiding having the edition to force new elements into the setting. In some ways 5E seems to be easier to customise to the setting than having it be the other way around which may have been the case with some previous editions. Or perhaps that had less to do with the editions even and more to do with the mindset of those doing the conversions.
Anyway, it seems like we are on the same page here
-Havard
Re: [5E] Classes for Blackmoor? - finarvyn - 02-21-2015
Don't get me wrong -- I have a preference for older versions of Blackmoor, but that is mostly tied to OD&D rules at the same time. Once you shift to a different rules set my tie to the older era of the campaign becomes less strong.
For example, running a "First Fantasy Campaign" based game with 4E rules would have been strange to me. FFC is very much a back-to-the-basics book and OD&D is a back-to-the-basics rules set so they fit well, but 4E has a totally different feel to it and one that doesn't feel very FFC-like to me.